The summer time Greece found out the weather disaster


Within the run-up to Greece’s two parliamentary elections in Would possibly and June, the weather was once of very little worry to the political events. Lower than 0.5% of pre-election speeches of the entire political leaders contained the phrases “surroundings” or “weather alternate”. The topic was once conspicuously absent even from the ultimate TV debate between the leaders of the rustic’s maximum distinguished events.

This turns out to move in opposition to the priorities of Greek voters. Consistent with the newest Eurobarometer survey, 94% of Greeks consider that “tackling weather alternate and environmental problems will have to be a concern to toughen public well being.” Some other survey via Metron Research discovered that 29% of Greeks imagine weather alternate the largest factor going through the planet these days, adopted via the destruction of the herbal surroundings (21%). On the other hand, on the subject of the largest problems going through Greece, a distinct image emerges: the price of residing tops the Greeks’ issues, adopted via the financial system and simplest then via environmental destruction (9%). 

This would possibly partially give an explanation for why Greece’s inexperienced events aren’t flourishing. Within the June elections, the Ecologist Vegetables won 21,188 votes, or 0.41%, whilst the Inexperienced & Red alliance were given 15,725 votes, or 0.3%

Against this, the climate-sceptic, conspiracy-minded far-right birthday celebration Niki (“Victory”) were given 3.69% of the vote, gaining 10 seats within the Greek parliament. Consistent with an editorial hosted at the birthday celebration’s web page “Through focused on carbon dioxide [emissions], the speculation of weather alternate has turn into the software for keeping up world energy and thru it, world wealth”. 

In a while after the June election, Greece skilled disastrous wildfires that brought about a minimum of 28 deaths and burned greater than 120,000 hectares of land. In September, the rustic’s central area of Thessaly was once hit via devastating floods. Finally, weather alternate made its look within the Greek political and media debate.

Of their protection of the environmental failures, a number of Greek media shops quoted English-language information stories. Fashionable government-friendly publications Efimerida and Newsbomb, relating to an editorial revealed in Deutsche Welle, titled, “Greece is at the vanguard of weather alternate”. Newsbomb additionally quoted the BBC’s identify “Floods in Greece: High Minister Mitsotakis warns of an excessively unequal fight with nature”.

Obtain the most productive of Ecu journalism directly on your inbox each Thursday

Ekathimerini, the English-language model of certainly one of Greece’s primary newspapers, quoted Mitsotakis telling CNN, “We did the most productive lets” in coping with the catastrophic fires. “I’m afraid that that is going to be the truth that spaces just like the Mediterranean will face someday”, Mitsotakis added. Those narratives have contributed to the depoliticisation of environmental failures in Greece’s public debate. 

This isn’t a brand new development. Again in 2018, former left-wing top minister and Syriza chief Alexis Tsipras reacted to the floods in Mandra and the wildfires in Mati, within the capital’s Attica area, pronouncing that Greece must replace civil coverage protocols as a result of “weather alternate method we can face extra widespread excessive climate occasions”. Then-opposition chief Mitsotakis responded mockingly, “Mr Tsipras found out these days that weather alternate reasons excessive climate occasions”. 

Polariasation and de-politicisation

The past due Eleni Kapetanaki-Briassoulis, a geographer and professor at College of the Aegean, warned in 2021 {that a} fatalistic acceptance of the affects of weather alternate shifts accountability to far away reasons, thereby sidelining “native (particular person and collective) selections and interventions on herbal assets”.

“The dominant narrative of weather alternate, via sprucing the size or slightly complicated the native/contextual with the worldwide/far off, exonerates a portion of the professional and unofficial culprits and redistributes the blame, spreading it over a bigger inhabitants,” Kapetanakis-Briassoulis wrote.

On the other hand, the federal government went one step additional, attacking the clinical neighborhood within the aftermath of remaining summer time’s failures. In September, when the Nationwide Observatory of Athens (NOA) reported a 195% building up in burnt spaces in spite of a 52% relief within the collection of wildfires in 2023 in comparison to the once a year moderate from 2002 to 2022, the federal government accused the Observatory of being politically motivated. Deputy Minister of Migration and Asylum Sofia Voultepsi spoke of a “propaganda of numbers”, whilst MP and previous minister Stelios Petsas referred to “political video games”, including, “I don’t like its function”.

In early December, the federal government moved from phrases to deeds, saying its goal to include the NOA into the Ministry of Local weather Disaster and Civil Coverage. Researchers from quite a lot of establishments oppose the alternate, mentioning issues over the independence of the Observatory.

Political controversies apart, remaining summer time’s environmental failures introduced the weather disaster to the fore, in all probability marking a metamorphosis in media attitudes. Consistent with an research via the Nationwide Community for Local weather Alternate CLIMPACT of over two thousand information pieces revealed on-line between 2009 and 2020, protection of the weather disaster via the Greek media was once missing for a number of causes.

First, reporters weren’t focused on detailed reporting about weather alternate, whilst 11% of the analysed content material reproduced weather sceptical perspectives. 2d, even supposing the effects of weather alternate are already tangible in Greece and around the globe, 28% of the analysed articles completely referred to weather affects anticipated at some unspecified time someday. Most effective 17% of them discussed the consequences of weather alternate within the provide.

3rd, the articles targeted totally on nationwide governments as chargeable for addressing weather alternate and its affects. Native and world actors (the EU, voters, native government, environmental teams, and NGOs) had been discussed much less regularly.

On a extra sure be aware, the research discovered that one in two information articles integrated statements via professionals. One in 3 contained statements via politicians, adopted via participants of civil society (14.5%), voters (12%), and trade representatives (9%).

As famous within the survey, the presence of scientists within the media can strengthen the general public’s figuring out of the hyperlink between weather alternate, human process, and herbal failures. Nonetheless, CLIMPACT stresses that on-line media discourse – which incessantly reproduces offline discourse – must turn into extra explanatory and to raised put across the urgency for political motion on weather alternate.

Alexandra Politaki, Ecu Local weather Pact ambassador in Greece, wrote in a contemporary article that the rustic lacks large-scale data and awareness-raising campaigns designed centrally and carried out over the years via state our bodies. As an alternative, persons are uncovered to “images of present or long term failures, […] fragmentary pictures that provide not anything greater than impressions. Thus, key ideas […] equivalent to adaptation, transition, weather neutrality, Ecu Inexperienced Deal, and Simply Transition Mechanism, are left with out huge figuring out”, argued Politaki.

Even the Nationwide Local weather Legislation, followed in Would possibly 2022 and aiming to scale back Greece’s greenhouse gasoline emissions via 55% via 2030 in comparison to 1990 ranges and internet 0 via 2050, didn’t obtain the visibility it deserved. The approval of the regulation, which a number of environmental NGOs imagine insufficient to satisfy the 1.5-degree goal, adopted a public session length of simplest two months between past due 2021 and early 2022.

This inadequate public session “has been mirrored within the Local weather Legislation, in addition to the loss of a complete means, intensity, and political imaginative and prescient,” says Politaki.

Prison threats

Political polarisation and susceptible media protection aren’t the one issues plaguing the general public debate on weather in Greece. Certainly, as consideration has grown round environmental problems, there has additionally been an building up in court cases in opposition to reporters via financial pursuits, together with corporations concerned within the power transition. Intimidatory criminal motion referred to as SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit In opposition to Public Participation) has focused reporters who discover environmental injury or file on environmental issues round large-scale mining and effort initiatives. 

Examples come with a lawsuit filed via renewable power corporate WRE HELLAS in opposition to Tasos Sarantis and the newspaper Efsyn for his or her reporting; one via a high-ranking government of Hellas Gold in opposition to the web information outlet Altherthess and journalist Stavroula Poulimeni, who reported on environmental air pollution hooked up to the corporate’s mining operations in Greece’s northern area of Halkidiki; and one via recycling corporate Antapodotiki Anakyklosi in opposition to journalist Thodoris Chondrogiannos for an article revealed within the unbiased information outlet Inside of Tale

Prison threats don’t simplest worry reporters. ONEX shipyards focused a neighborhood environmental NGO at the Cycladic island of Syros; a wind power corporate sued 100 citizens of the island of Tinos for mobilising in opposition to the set up of wind generators; and every other wind energy corporate filed a lawsuit in opposition to 9 criminal entities on Andros, additionally within the Cyclades, once they had contested the building of a highway via the corporate. The listing may just pass on.

“Those SLAPPs don’t simplest try to impede our accountability to offer data unbiased of political and financial pursuits. It is usually the proper to obtain data this is progressively being limited’’, explains Stavroula Poulimeni. Thankfully, maximum native communities and lots of environmental organisations stood in unity with reporters and NGOs in opposition to the burgeoning business of intimidatory court cases.

But silence prevailed in many of the nation’s mainstream media. Right here, for the weather and surroundings to be remembered, it took flooded cities, mud-covered villages and 1.7 million acres burnt in one summer time.

Since 2016, Greece has had a Nationwide Technique for Local weather Alternate Adaptation (NSCA), in line with a 2011 learn about via the Financial institution of Greece. On the other hand, seven years after the method was once advanced, Greece has but to approve the 13 Regional Local weather Alternate Adaptation Plans (PESPACA) had to put into effect the NSCA. Little turns out to have modified even after remaining summer time, and the media comprises little reporting at the subject.

Higher media independence is the most important if we’re to give you the public with high quality data on weather affects and responses whilst protecting politicians responsible. There could also be an pressing want to “co-educate” scientists and reporters to assist them higher keep in touch the complexities of weather science and higher give an explanation for the social and financial affects of the disaster.

This newsletter is a part of a chain devoted to weather discourse within the Ecu media. This mission is organised via the Inexperienced Ecu Basis with the make stronger of the Ecu Parliament, and in collaboration with Voxeurop and the Inexperienced Ecu Magazine.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:


More like this