Interpreting Iran’s UNGA schedule: Courses realized from previous CICA summits


When the president of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Ebrahim Raisi, visits New York for the outlet of the United Countries Common Meeting (UNGA) this week, he’ll attempt to mission a way of self assurance. Since his inauguration in August 2021, Raisi’s management has scored a sequence of overseas coverage wins, which he would possibly smartly level to: Iran’s accession to the Shanghai Cooperation Group (SCO), normalization of family members with Saudi Arabia, and a call for participation to sign up for BRICS (firstly together with Brazil, Russia, India, China, and, later, South Africa) have all befell below his watch. The regime additionally controlled to continue to exist severe protests after the dying of Mahsa Amini, which began to devour the Islamic Republic whilst Raisi was once in Turtle Bay closing 12 months.

He’s going to search to exhibit that Tehran has neutralized global sanctions, ended its isolation, and inverted the Abraham Accords by means of fighting its growth into an anti-Iranian bloc. Coupled with a hearty dose of poisonous anti-Israeli rhetoric, Tehran will search to mission that it’s Israel, no longer Iran, this is remoted, while the Iranian regime is purportedly dedicated to constructing ties with its community. A possible deliberate assembly of overseas ministers from Iran, Iraq, and member states of the Gulf Cooperation Council at the sidelines of UNGA — being billed as a brand new, nascent regional discussion discussion board — will support this belief.

Then again, one accumulating in New York is sure to upend the Islamic Republic’s mythmaking, and that’s a casual ministerial council assembly of the Convention on Interplay and Self belief-Construction Measures in Asia (CICA), scheduled for Sept. 21. CICA was once based in 1999 as “a multi-national discussion board for boosting cooperation against peace, safety, and steadiness in Asia.” Each Iran and Israel are member states, to not point out the Islamic Republic’s Arab opponents, which ceaselessly makes for an uncomfortable dynamic. It additionally demonstrates the constraints of regional discussion platforms at a time when international locations within the Heart East are pursuing de-escalation and engagement.

Violating CICA’s founding paperwork, and Iran and Israel’s shut encounters

One of the crucial elementary paperwork of CICA is the 1999 Declaration at the Rules Guiding Family members Between the CICA Member-States. It says that “member-states shall chorus of their family members from the direct or oblique danger or use of pressure in opposition to the sovereignty, territorial integrity, and political independence of the states, or another means inconsistent with the UN Constitution and with the prevailing declaration. No issues could also be invoked to warrant hotel to the danger or use of pressure in contravention of this theory.” Regardless of this dedication as a CICA member, on the other hand, the Islamic Republic has been threatening to wipe Israel off the map for over 4 a long time.

In June 2006, at the second one CICA summit, in Almaty, Shimon Peres, then serving as Israel’s vice premier and minister for the improvement of the Negev and Galilee, got here face-to-face with Abbas Araghchi, Iran’s deputy overseas minister on the time. If truth be told, each males posed in combination for a “magnificence photograph” and signed onto a joint declaration after the summit that condemned “terrorism in all its bureaucracy and manifestations and rigidity[ed] that there’s no justification for terrorism,” committing to multilateralism so as to battle the danger and “keep away from double requirements” in its eradication. This got here handiest weeks earlier than the 2006 Lebanon Warfare, which was once brought about by means of Tehran’s proxy Hezbollah abducting two Israeli squaddies and later firing 4,000 rockets at Israel, ensuing within the deaths of a few 50 Israeli civilians. Hezbollah is designated by means of the US as a overseas 15 May Organization.

Photo credit VYACHESLAV OSELEDKO/AFP via Getty Images
Photograph above: Israeli High Minister Shimon Peres and Iranian Deputy Overseas Minister Abbas Araghchi pose in combination in a “circle of relatives photograph” with different leaders of the member states of the Convention on Interplay and Self belief-Construction Measures in Asia (CICA) at group’s summit in Almaty, Kazakhstan, June 17, 2006. Photograph credit score VYACHESLAV OSELEDKO/AFP by way of Getty Photographs.


On the subsequent CICA summit, in 2010, Iran’s then-President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad made an look along Israel’s ambassador to Turkey, Gabby Levy. At a press convention at CICA, Ahmadinejad railed in opposition to Israel, pronouncing, “the devilish sound of the uncultured Zionists was once popping out from their deceit […] they had been conserving up the flag of the satan.” Levy walked out in protest, in spite of each males later showing in combination as soon as once more in a bunch photograph. After this assembly, a equivalent declaration to that from the 2006 summit adopted, which noticed member states “draw particular consideration to the need of stopping terrorism via countering ideologies that justify it.” However all over early 2012, Iran’s govt spearheaded tried assaults in opposition to Israeli diplomats in Azerbaijan, India, Georgia, and Thailand; many noticed this marketing campaign as a reaction to Israeli assassinations of nuclear scientists in Iran who helped advance its nuclear program, which threatened the Jewish state. That’s not to say Iran’s proxy Hezbollah’s bombing of a bus wearing Israeli vacationers in Bulgaria in July 2012 and Israeli High Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s well-known crimson line speech earlier than the U.N. Common Meeting that September, the place he threatened the Islamic Republic because it complex its nuclear program. CICA declarations thus had no affect at the bilateral rigidity between each international locations.

This development of Iranian and Israeli representatives each collaborating in CICA summitry and conferences has persevered for years, whilst regional tensions between the longtime nemeses exploded. Within the summits that happened each and every 4 years, on maximum events, Iran’s presidents have historically represented the Islamic Republic. However Israel has taken a unique means, sending lower-level diplomats to constitute the Jewish state, with the exception of Shimon Peres in 2006.

Thus, all the way through the closing CICA summit, in October 2022, Tehran despatched President Raisi. Status on the subject of him within the circle of relatives photograph is Simona Halperin, deputy director-general of Israel’s Ministry of Overseas Affairs’ Division of Eurasia and the Balkans, who led the Israeli delegation on the summit. And in spite of the 2 international locations’ joint club in CICA, David Barnea, the director of Israel’s Mossad, its overseas intelligence group, disclosed this month that the Israeli safety products and services and their companions thwarted 27 plots hatched by means of the Islamic Republic to focus on Jews and Israelis this 12 months on my own. Naturally, one of these dynamic violates CICA’s founding paperwork.

The awkwardness has prolonged to working-level CICA discussions. As an example, Kazakhstan’s ministries of overseas affairs and protection, together with CICA, hosted a seminar in August 2023 at the construction of military-political confidence-building measures, that includes 14 representatives from CICA member-states. Within the footage that circulated of the assembly, Iranian navy officials looked to be provide on the similar desk as an Israeli navy officer. But this participation has finished not anything to change the danger belief and strategic posture of each international locations.

Past Israel

CICA’s constraints lengthen past Israel. The declaration additionally stipulates that “member-states shall chorus from any intervention within the inside affairs of some other member-state.” Then again, the Islamic Republic has been violating that proviso with impunity in relation to some other CICA member, Bahrain. It has funded and resourced the al-Ashtar Brigades, that have attacked Bahraini police and safety forces. In 2015, Manama even accused Tehran of fomenting “confessional sedition.”

The United Arab Emirates, some other CICA nation, has additionally had a hard historical past with Tehran in spite of the hot thaw in ties after the recovery of complete diplomatic family members closing 12 months. Ignoring the hovering pledges to abstain from the usage of pressure in opposition to some other CICA member state, Tehran’s companions in Yemen, the Houthis, introduced missiles at Emirati territory in 2022 and likewise plotted assaults on UAE diplomatic amenities in Africa.

Ditto in Iraq, which could also be a CICA member state. The Islamic Republic has used Iraq as a launchpad for assaults in opposition to different CICA participants, no longer least Israel. As an example, in 2022 U.S. fighter jets downed two Iranian drones over Iraq that had been armed to blow up on Israeli territory. Within the Declaration of CICA Rules report, it spells out very obviously that “the member-states shall admire the territorial integrity of one another” and foreswear the usage of pressure in opposition to some other member state. Tehran would most likely argue it’s performing in self-defense, which is preserved on this report; however Israel would counter that it too is making an attempt to discourage and protect itself from the Islamic Republic, which, every day, hands and price range terrorist militias intent on its destruction.

Different organizations except for CICA have additionally existed for years with out converting the basics of Tehran’s innovative overseas coverage. This may also be noticed within the complaints of the Group of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), which counts Iran and its regional opponents, together with Saudi Arabia and the UAE, as participants. The OIC predates the Islamic Revolution of 1979, but its venture “to paintings for the agreement of conflicts and disputes involving member-states” has no longer moved the needle in a transformative means.

The Islamic Republic is already eyeing the usage of U.N. Safety Council Answer 598, which referred to as for a ceasefire all the way through the Iran-Iraq Warfare in 1987, as a mechanism to advertise long term regional discussion. Answer 598 in particular “requests the [U.N.] secretary-general to inspect, in session with Iran and Iraq and with different states of the area, measures to improve the safety and steadiness of the area.”

Then again, the above historical past demonstrates that whilst Iran will try to reveal its excellent neighborliness on the UNGA opening by means of selling and regarding its club in more than a few regional discussion boards, their life has traditionally no longer moderated Iranian habits. The assumptions that undergird their software are misguided, because the Islamic Republic of Iran — in spite of occasional tactical changes to keep the longevity of the regime — is a innovative energy that seeks to dominate, no longer combine with the area.


Jason M. Brodsky is the coverage director of United In opposition to Nuclear Iran (UANI) and a non-resident pupil on the Heart East Institute’s Iran Program. His analysis specialties come with Iranian management dynamics, the Islamic Progressive Guard Corps (IRGC), and Iran’s courting with Israel. He’s on Twitter @JasonMBrodsky.

Photograph by means of Iranian Presidency/Anadolu Company by way of Getty Photographs

The Heart East Institute (MEI) is an impartial, non-partisan, non-for-profit, instructional group. It does no longer interact in advocacy and its students’ critiques are their very own. MEI welcomes monetary donations, however keeps sole editorial regulate over its paintings and its publications replicate handiest the authors’ perspectives. For an inventory of MEI donors, please click on here.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:


More like this